How can homeless people afford cell phones?

Canadian Observatory on Homelessness/Homeless Hub: York University
October 24, 2014
Categories: Ask the Hub

Technology, with all its rapid growth and innovation, has long been considered an indicator of status. Perhaps this is why some people think of cell phones as luxury items, despite the fact that the vast majority of Canadians have them. (83% of households had at least one active cell phone in 2013, according to the last Statistics Canada survey.)

As you probably know from carrying around your own iPhone, Blackberry or Android device, cell phones have become a necessity for many. With texting, emailing and mobile-exclusive phone use rising, cell phones are often the only devices with which people can adequately manage their communications. We use our phones to stay in touch with friends and family, find and apply to jobs, feel safe and more.

This is also true for people experiencing homelessness. They tend to face more barriers—stigma and financial difficulties, just to name a few—to technology, but many manage to overcome them.

Most people experiencing homelessness have cell phones

Research shows that many homeless people have cell phones. In Karin M. Eyrich-Garg’s study of homeless people in Philadelphia, 44% of the adult participants already had their own cell phones. (Amongst those participants, 80% owned, 18% borrowed long-term, and 2% rented.)

In another study, 70.7% of homeless patients visiting emergency departments had cell phones, compared to 85.9% of people who were stably housed.  

Similarly, in Melody Kim, Melissa Cameron and Alex Fung’s study in San Diego, 8 out of 11 participants had cell phones and the other 2 were seeking replacements.

Evidently, people with cell phones are a significant portion of the overall homeless population and tend to be more the norm than the exception.

Used cell phones collected for a drive

They can be more affordable than you think 

As noted in our Homelessness 101 section, most people experiencing homeless do so for less than a month. During such short periods of homelessness, it is entirely possible for people to keep their phones in service.

Yet with some of us buying brand new smartphones and paying more than $100 in talk and data services, one might wonder how a cell phone bill gets paid when money is tight. The answer is that monthly costs depend on the kind of cell phone, the carrier and the kind of service.

A report by Wall Communications tracked four levels of monthly talk, data and text packages. They found that the average cell phone bill is between $34 and $80 a month. In Eyrich-Garg’s study, about half the participants had a monthly plan, with various costs and strategies for paying them.

In Canada, we have some companies that provide cheaper monthly plans, many of which have a mix of talk minutes and text messages. Here’s a few of them, with some of their low- to mid-range plan price ranges: Wind ($25-$35), Koodo ($35-$40), MobilCity ($25-$35), PC Mobile ($29-$39), Virgin Mobile Canada ($35-$40) and Public ($19-$25).

Pay-as-you go cell phones are a much more affordable option that allows users to pay in advance and only for what they use. In the San Diego study, this was the most popular kind of cell phone service that homeless people used.

When it comes to phones themselves, people experiencing homelessness don’t always have phones from when they were stably housed. Some use models from friends or family, while others find affordable devices at pawn shops, secondhand stores and even some dollar stores. Using prepaid minute cards, having a cell phone can cost less than $20 a month.

Some shelters and community programs, like Lifeline in California, even give phones away for free. In Vancouver, the P.H.S. Community Services Society collected used cell phones without SIM cards for seniors living in poverty, so they could still dial 911 in an emergency.

Why do homeless people need cell phones?

As I mentioned above, people experiencing homelessness need cell phones for many of the same reasons that people who are stably housed do. In an article for Mobledia, Kat Aschayara wrote about how important one homeless man’s Blackberry is to him:

“His phone, then, functions as an important conduit. On the surface, it’s his most important, practical tool. He can call places for work with it. He can call up shelters and other social services to see what’s available. He calls public transportation to find out which bus lines are running and check out schedules. E-mail and text is especially important. He can reach out to friends to see if he can crash with them for a night or two, especially if the weather is rough.”

One participant in Kim, Cameron and Feng’s study said: “The amount of help they can be is substantial. [Cellphones are] a way to communicate with others to learn where resources are, when opportunities present themselves.”

Safety is also a factor. Another participant in the same study pointed out that without a landline and with fewer and fewer payphones available, he simply had to get his own phone.

Finally, simply being connected to other people is important not only for sharing resources and employment opportunities, but also for health and well being. As Euryich-Garg’s study found, social connectedness was one of the primary reasons that homeless individuals used computers. She wrote: “Mobile phones offer a connection to others without the physical constraints of landlines and may make communication and, therefore, access to one’s social support network more feasible for homeless individuals. This, in turn, could lead toward better health outcomes.” 

Stephen Hwang et al. came to similar conclusions in their study of multidimensional social support and the health of homeless individuals, writing: “…perceived access to specific types of social support derived from social networks of friends, family, and/or neighbors can have a protective influence on multiple health outcomes among homeless individuals.”

Even social connections with strangers have value. As Margaret Rock wrote in an article on 2machines:

“Homeless bloggers, for instance, are a godsend for those who find themselves in similar circumstances. Those on the brink are increasingly reaching out on Twitter, using homelessness-related hashtags or topics. One name that comes up often is Mark Horvath, who goes by the Twitter handle, @hardlynormal. His dedication to providing a forum for homeless to share resources, advice and tips gives others a much-needed path to navigate their new, scary world.”

For many people experiencing homelessness, cell phones aren’t a luxury. They’re a necessity. 

This post is part of our Friday "Ask the Hub" blog series. Have a homeless-related question you want answered? E-mail us at thehub@edu.yorku.ca and we will provide a research-based answer.

Photo by Faye Bayko.

Emma Woolley is a 2016 graduate of York University's Bachelor of Social Work program with a background in publishing, freelance writing and digital communications. Her interest in affordable housing, homelessness, 2LGBTQ rights, and social justice led her to work with The Homeless Hub. Emma is now pursuing her Master of Social Work at The University of Toronto, where she is focusing on anti-oppressive, strengths-based, recovery-oriented, and critical approaches to mental health care.

Comments

gjlypgan
6:11 AM 14/05/2015

The answer, she explains, was concept stores. <a href=http://raybanoutlet.mishaproductions.com/>ray ban outlet</a> Thailand executed prisoners by a machine gun or automatic rifle fired by an executioner until 2002, when the method was changed to lethal injection. There have been no executions since 2009. m <a href=http://michaelkorsoutlet.safaricamkenya.com/>michael kors outlet</a>
Bairstow then began to take command as he drove Breese for four and six then pulled Collingwood into the crowd over square leg. <a href=http://michaelkorsoutlet.safaricamkenya.com/>michael kors bags outlet</a> 鈥淗e鈥檚 been in with the likes of McCloskey and Nurse and they are people I feel I can not only mix it with, but beat. I do believe I can mix it with the best of them and that鈥檚 why the move to Matchroom and being able to fight in front of Sky Sports excites me.鈥?
She warned against letting IS 鈥渉ijack鈥?the identity of Islam, arguing that it would allow them to set up a 鈥渂attle of civilisations鈥? 鈥淧eople call them ISIS, I would love to drop that first 鈥業鈥?because there is noth-ing Islamic about them. They have nothing to do with faith and everything to do with fanaticism,鈥?she said. 鈥淭hey want to be called Islamic because it gives them legitimacy and also it means that any action taken against them would automatically be called a war against Islam. 鈥淭hey want that clash of civilisation that people talk about,鈥?she added. <a href=http://louboutinoutlet.mindbodyease.com/>louboutin outlet</a> As part of a transportation study led by the Wisconsin Center District, with the City of Milwaukee, Milwaukee County and the Metropolitan Milwaukee Association of Commerce, downtown Milwaukee is exploring a streetcar and rapid transit systems. f <a href=http://hollisteroutlet.pinkstaffscience.com/>hollister outlet</a>
That left Middlesbrough, who did go close in the opening few minutes when Leadbitter鈥檚 brilliant free-kick dipped just over the bar, with an uphill struggle and that became even bigger when McCormack slotted in his first penalty nine minutes after the break when he had been clumsily shoved to the floor by Daniel Ayala. <a href=http://louboutinoutlet.mindbodyease.com/>louboutin</a> For example, the DNR has taken up 22 sand mining cases since March 30, 2013, with settlements so far totaling $360,000. Cases often take a year or more to complete. Sand mining has grown sharply in recent years. Despite the prosecutions, local groups and some communities in mining country complain the DNR should be doing more.
g "I will miss the great friends I made and just being around my teammates, because those are the guys you do it for," Mitchell said. "You are used to seeing them every day, and then all of a sudden you go months or years without seeing them." <a href=http://hollisteroutlet.pinkstaffscience.com/>hollister outlet</a> Launched on a college campus, it has since spread outside to the wider community. But colleges and universities are where it remains most popular, with college-aged young people making up about 95 per cent of its devotees, according to its other co-founder, . <a href=http://oakleysoutlet.rinosac.com/>oakley outlet</a>
His loan came to an end last Friday, but he has already spelled out his desire to return to the Riverside next season, and no matter what league his side are playing in, Aitor Karanka is likely to take him up on his offer. <a href=http://louboutinoutlet.mindbodyease.com/>http://louboutinoutlet.mindbody... The age gap never worried him, he reflects. " I was in love - and still am - and I thought this was going to be my last chance for happiness. I know she'll be with me until the end of the road." http://louboutinoutlet.mindbodyease.com
Answer: You must contact the Sentences Enforcement Depart-ment at the Ministry of Interior or you can file a complaint in this regard on the Ministry of Interior website: www.moi.gov.kw/ portal/ venglish It is possible that the information on the Kuwait court order, the arrest warrant and also the travel ban has so far not been entered on the Interior Ministry computers. <a href=http://guccioutlet.rickcagle.com/>gucci outlet store</a> 鈥淗e was taught to blow darts a very early age by his father who was in a wheelchair and had developed the dart-blowing technique.鈥?i <a href=http://katespadeoutlet.pimandmarleen.com/>kate spade bags</a>
Why not print the figures showing how many tons of each waste DBC collect every fortnight together with the prices per ton they are selling it for - Theres a challenge for you - its called reporting ! <a href=http://michaelkorsoutlet.safaricamkenya.com/>michael kors handbags</a> The 5-6 senior guard from Oklahoma Wesleyan almost single-handedly led her team from the jaws of defeat in the final game of Wednesday night鈥檚 NAIA Division II Women鈥檚 Basketball Championship.
Those closed trails include: <a href=http://oakleysoutlet.rinosac.com/>oakley outlet</a> </table>
After finishing his doctorate, Auer was hired by the Hutchinson cancer center to work alongside epidemiologists and MDs. <a href=http://oakleysoutlet.rinosac.com/>oakley glasses</a> "All kinds of people love it; it spreads right across the nation, which is great," he explains.
Brookfield Central Invite at Wanaki Golf Course, 1 p.m. Wednesday: This best-ball invite features a loaded field that includes Arrowhead, Milwaukee Marquette, Slinger, Homestead and Cedarburg. <a href=http://louboutinoutlet.mindbodyease.com/>christian louboutin outlet</a> A measles outbreak is threatening children in the camp and nearby communities.
c To Bat: A N Petersen, N R D Compton, J <a href=http://louboutinoutlet.mindbodyease.com/>louboutinoutlet.mindbodyease.co... Richard added: 鈥淧aula Dunn will sit down and look at the athletics team potentials, not just their track times but also their abilities to succeed in Rio at the Games.
Researchers said the higher prescribing rates for Medicaid might be due to insurance coverage, differences in use of health care services and possible differences in underlying health conditions. <a href=http://louboutinoutlet.mindbodyease.com/>christian louboutin outlet</a> Crafton finished 18th as the fill-in for KyleBusch after Busch was injured Saturday in a crash in the Xfinity Series opener. i <a href=http://oakleysoutlet.rinosac.com/>oakley outlet</a>
When the two sides meet - most recently in the Capital One Cup when Tony Mowbray and Martin O鈥橬eill were in charge of Boro and Sunderland in 2012- there is considerably bad blood between the fans who are only united by a dislike of . <a href=http://oakleysoutlet.rinosac.com/>oakleysoutlet.rinosac.com</a> "They are basically, you know, saving my life and they don't even know who I am," Jeanine said.
n Capewell called for government action to support healthy food choices, zero cigarettes, and minimal junk food and sodas. In the United States in particular, he said, the nation has done a "great job" on tobacco control and "now needs to apply the same lessons to food: control of sugar, sodium and saturated animal fats." <a href=http://raybanoutlet.mishaproductions.com/>ray ban sunglasses</a> Within days, Britain s aptly named HMS Bulwark and the German supply ship Berlin could be steaming to the heart of the Mediterranean in the biggest sign of the European Union s belated commitment to contain the tide of rickety ships making the perilous crossing. u
Odds: 5-1 <a href=http://hollisteroutlet.pinkstaffscience.com/>http://hollisteroutlet.pink... September 7:Held in conjunction with Plant Heritage, specialist nurseries will be onsite selling a range of quality plants. <a href=http://hollisteroutlet.pinkstaffscience.com/>hollister co</a>
In six seasons as the varsity football coach at Eastern Wayne, Williams' teams saw a lot of success. Over the course of the last two seasons, Eastern Wayne has appeared in two consecutive 3-A Eastern Regional finals. <a href=http://guccioutlet.rickcagle.com/>gucci outlet store</a> Cyclone Pam as it headed south after slamming Vanuatu, while Cyclone Nathan lingers of the Queensland coast Photo: EarthWindMap g <a href=http://hollisteroutlet.pinkstaffscience.com/>hollister outlet</a>
It would welcome volunteers, both able-bodied and people with disabilities, who could act as mentors to help members get the most out of sessions. <a href=http://guccioutlet.rickcagle.com/>gucci outlet store</a> 鈥淭hose are the qualities I look for.鈥?
KUWAIT CITY, April 10: Minister of Education and Higher Education Dr Bader Al-Essa affirmed the prevalence of violence in Kuwait, indicating that there are various causes for this problem such as the low-level of education, absence of the role of family and non-application of law, reports Al-Rai daily. He said Ministry of Education and Higher Education is an educational institution and are not collecting any sharp objects from students, but it will support any security procedure taken by Ministry of Interior to stop such kind of bad behaviors. <a href=http://michaelkorsoutlet.safaricamkenya.com/>michael kors bags outlet</a> Unfortunately, as he was travelling home, he fell foul of Duke Leopold of Austria, who took him prisoner and handed him over to the Emperor Henry VI from whom he had to be ransomed. v <a href=http://guccioutlet.rickcagle.com/>gucci outlet</a>
And if you discover where I live, I might just treat you to a proper pasty, a pint of Tribute and some tales of dark doings with them wreckers, smugglers and revenue men! <a href=http://guccioutlet.rickcagle.com/>gucci outlet</a> 24-6-60-1. Leach 11-4-24-1.

homeless110
10:23 AM 24/10/2014

alot of people discount the importance and true value of the homeless having a cell phone. not only is it a safety issue, but it is a necessity in today's world if you even hope to find employment. also making and keeping essential appointments like the doctor or other requires a cell phone. it's not a luxury...it's an essential.
I addressed this on the negative side on my blog then had to recant and admit I was wrong about the homeless having cell phones and the internet.

I Could Be Wrong...Again
http://wilmingtonhomeless.weebly.com/homeless-blog/archives/01-2014
the entry is dated 1/23/14

Add Comment

Recent Tweets

Content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial No Derivatives License

The analysis and interpretations contained in the blog posts are those of the individual contributors and do not necessarily represent the views of the Canadian Observatory on Homelessness.